Oreo. Peanut Butter Cup. Madness.

This post may contain affiliate links and ads. Read our disclosure policy here.

Oreo Reeses Madness cut open title

The husband is typically a very helpful guy.

One way that he is NOT helpful is when he finds new dessert ideas as they surface in his Facebook feed.  Then he gets a snow day off of work.


These delectable desserts are absolutely mouthwatering.  They are also incredibly sweet – making it impossible for me to eat more than one at a time.  They are just as easy (if not easier) than whipping up a batch of cookies, so don’t be intimidated.

The awesome thing about any dessert that you dip in chocolate is that you can change up the toppings to reflect the current season or holiday.  Throw a few in a clear bag or tin and you have an instant gift.

You will need:

  1. Chocolate Melting Chips (we tend to use Wilton brand or chocolate bark from ALDI)
  2. Oreo Cookies
  3. Reese’s Peanut Butter Cups (the larger size)
  4. Toppings (optional)

How to make:

Place the chocolate in your melter.  I love my Wilton Chocolate Pro Electric Melting Pot.  I bought it almost 3 years ago, it’s a great little tool – I use it often!

As you wait for the chocolate to melt, you can prepare your cookie concoctions.

First, you need an Oreo.

Oreo Reeses Madness oreo

Gently lift the top off of the Oreo, leaving as much of the filling intact as possible.  I didn’t do a perfect job with this one. LOL

Oreo Reeses Madness open oreo

Put a peanut butter cup on top of the cookie’s filling and then put the cookie top back in place.

Oreo Reeses Madness predipping

As soon as your chocolate has completely melted, you are ready!

We tried dipping the cookie/pb cup combo but ran into difficultly because it was so large/bulky.  So instead of dipping, we placed each cookie on a big piece of wax paper and drizzled chocolate on top and over the sides.

Oreo Reeses Madness melted chocolate

Oreo Reeses Madness dipped chocolate 1

At this point the cookies sat on the wax paper until the chocolate had hardened.  Then we flipped them over and covered the bottoms with chocolate.

Oreo Reeses Madness cooling off 2

Now it’s time to add the toppings!

Our toppings were super simple… on some we drizzled white chocolate.  On others we used leftover Christmas candy canes that we crushed and sprinkled on top.  On the last few we placed several M&Ms.

Oreo Reeses Madness toppings

And if you think they look good from the outside…

Oreo Reeses Madness final 1

Take a look at the inside!

Oreo Reeses Madness cut open 3

Oh!  Em!  Gee!

And guess what?

They taste every bit as good as they look.  Maybe even better.  ;)

oreo reeses collage


Oreo Peanut Butter Cup Madness

Check out the other recipes that have posted, including some 21 Day Fix recipes! While you’re at it, make sure you browse the The Ultimate MamaCheaps.com Recipe Collection.

Other posts you might enjoy…

Overnight Oats Berries Banana Honey WalnutsTurkey Mini Meatloaf 21 Day Fix Mealfire truck birthday cupcake desserts21 day fix lunch chicken sausage quinoa squashstrawberry shortcake sundaedisney snacks magic kingdomHow to Ship Snacks (and More) to Your Disney Resortdisney world magic kingdom entrance pricing

Leave a Comment